When you think of boating, you likely imagine sunny days with the wind in your hair and the warmth of summer beckoning boaters out on the water. However, Spartanburg, like many areas, experiences boating year-round, and with that comes a surprising number of boating under the influence (BUI) charges during the winter months. Although boating activity generally slows down in the colder months, the reality is that alcohol-related boating offenses are still prevalent, even when the weather isn’t ideal for a day out on the lake.

350+ Reviews
5.0 Star Average

avvo clients choice-DUI

In this discussion, we’ll explore why wintertime BUI cases happen, the conditions that contribute to these offenses, and how legal professionals defend those accused of boating under the influence during this off-season. Despite reduced boating activity, winter is not without its own set of risks and challenges that can lead to BUI charges.

Why Winter BUI Cases Happen

While summer tends to be the peak boating season, it’s important to remember that boating doesn’t stop just because the weather turns colder. Spartanburg is home to many waterways, and although fewer boats may be out during the winter months, those that are still on the water can face the same risks and dangers that lead to alcohol-related offenses.

Holiday Gatherings and Winter Parties

One of the main reasons for the continuation of BUI charges during the winter season is the occurrence of private gatherings on the water. While summer is typically associated with major boating events, the winter months bring about holidays such as Christmas, New Year’s, and even Thanksgiving, all of which lead people to gather on their boats for small celebrations. The holidays are a time when people indulge, and alcohol consumption is often part of the celebrations. For some, a few drinks while enjoying the beauty of the lake in winter can quickly lead to impairment. As a result, when law enforcement conducts checks, they can find individuals with elevated blood alcohol content (BAC), leading to potential BUI charges.

Unpredictable Winter Weather and Hazards

Boating in winter presents unique challenges. Spartanburg, with its unpredictable weather patterns, often experiences fog, icy conditions, and low visibility on its lakes. These winter hazards increase the likelihood of accidents. Boaters may not always be prepared for the risks that winter conditions present. For instance, a sudden change in temperature or foggy mornings can catch boaters off guard, especially if they’ve been drinking. Even a small lapse in concentration or a misjudgment while navigating can cause accidents, and alcohol consumption only exacerbates the likelihood of such errors. The resulting accidents often lead to investigations, and alcohol impairment can contribute to BUI charges.

Fishing and Hunting Season on the Water

Many people continue to use their boats during winter for fishing and hunting purposes. Fishing, for example, is a popular winter pastime, and it’s not uncommon for individuals to consume alcohol while out on the water, particularly on long fishing trips. In some cases, alcohol consumption may not be initially noticeable or dangerous, but after several hours on the water, the effects can kick in. Winter fishing and hunting trips can quickly escalate to impaired boating, especially if individuals are using alcohol to stay warm or simply to pass the time.

Boating Without Proper Safety Preparation

Boaters often underestimate the risks of winter boating because they assume it is a much safer activity due to fewer people on the water. However, winter boating can still involve long hours spent in the elements, and the cold temperatures may cause hypothermia or other health issues. Boaters are typically less prepared for these dangers, and the consumption of alcohol can make them more vulnerable to these hazards. Alcohol can dull reaction times and impair judgment, which is dangerous on any body of water but especially in winter when the conditions themselves create additional risks.

"He has an innate ability to convey to clients what really matters in their cases."

"John Bateman is my absolute go to peer in the legal field when it comes to questions about DUI. . . . He has an innate ability to convey to clients what really matters in their cases. As a fellow attorney, I highly recommend John to anyone in the SC or NC areas who are looking for... legal representation when facing a DUI charge."

M. Brock

"An excellent DUI attorney. He has received the same field sobriety test training as all police officers in the State"

"John is an excellent DUI attorney. He has received the same field sobriety test training as all police officers in the State, and also the same training as the people who are the instructors of the police officer training courses on field sobriety tests. He is very passionate about DUI's and I recommend him often to people who are facing serious charges in the upstate area."

P. Hammond

"He cares for each of his clients and works extremely hard to achieve results."

"Very knowledgeable and thorough in his preparation and representation of his clients. He cares for each of his clients and works extremely hard to achieve results. I highly recommend this lawyer."

C. Grubbs

Legal Defenses for BUI Charges in Winter

For individuals facing BUI charges during the off-season, there are several legal defenses that can be employed. In many cases, the circumstances surrounding the winter months can create the perfect storm for defense attorneys to challenge the validity of the charges. Below are a few of the most common defenses:

Challenging Alcohol Impairment Claims

A central element of any BUI case is proving that the individual was impaired by alcohol. In some cases, individuals accused of boating under the influence may not have actually been impaired at the time of the arrest. Breathalyzer tests, for example, are often used to assess blood alcohol content (BAC), but these tests are not infallible. If there is any question regarding the accuracy of the testing method or the procedures followed during the testing process, the defense can challenge the validity of the results. A faulty breathalyzer reading, improper handling of evidence, or failure to follow proper testing protocols can lead to the dismissal of charges.

Related Videos

Refusing Field Sobriety Tests

Choosing a DUI Attorney

Faulty Arrest Procedures or Lack of Probable Cause

In some cases, a BUI arrest may have been made without proper justification or probable cause. For example, if law enforcement pulls a boat over or conducts a checkpoint without reasonable suspicion of impairment, the arrest may be deemed unlawful. Additionally, if the officer failed to follow proper procedure during the arrest, such as failing to inform the individual of their rights or improperly handling evidence, the defense could argue that the arrest was invalid and the charges should be dropped.

Medical Conditions or Temporary Alcohol Use

An individual charged with BUI may be able to argue that their alcohol consumption was not an attempt to become impaired or intoxicated, but rather a temporary use of alcohol for medicinal purposes or to combat the cold. For example, if an individual consumed a small amount of alcohol to keep warm in freezing temperatures, it might be possible to argue that the alcohol wasn’t consumed to impair their boating ability but instead served a specific, temporary function.

Inaccurate Witness Testimony or Officer Testimony

One of the strongest ways to defend against a BUI charge is by challenging the officer’s testimony or witness statements. If the officer or witnesses fail to provide a clear and accurate account of events leading to the arrest, the defense could argue that there is insufficient evidence to support the claim of alcohol impairment. Discrepancies in the officer’s report, such as inconsistencies in the description of the boat’s movements, behavior, or field sobriety tests, may be used to show that the arrest was not justified.

Boater’s Rights and Consent Issues

Boating under the influence charges also involve legal considerations around implied consent. In some cases, individuals who refuse to take field sobriety tests or breathalyzer tests may face charges based on their refusal to cooperate. However, a defense attorney may challenge whether the boater was properly informed of their rights or if the refusal was in any way coerced. This may be particularly relevant in cases where an individual was not clearly advised about the consequences of refusal or was not properly read their rights. Despite the belief that BUI cases are strictly a summer concern, Spartanburg’s waterways continue to see incidents related to alcohol consumption during the winter months. Whether it’s a holiday gathering, winter fishing trip, or the unexpected challenges of winter weather, alcohol-related boating offenses remain a serious concern in Spartanburg. As we’ve seen, defense attorneys can successfully challenge these charges using a variety of legal defenses, especially when the conditions surrounding winter boating complicate the situation. If you or someone you know is facing a BUI charge in Spartanburg during the off-season, it’s essential to have an experienced defense attorney on your side. With the right legal strategy and a thorough understanding of the unique aspects of wintertime BUI cases, you can ensure that your case is handled effectively. Contact The Bateman Law Firm today to discuss your situation and get the expert defense you need.

(864) 406-3004

Boating Under the Influence

Spartanburg BUI in the Off-Season: Why Winter Alcohol-Related Boat Cases Still Happen—and How They’re Defended